Teeling Blackpitts Peated Irish Whisky (NAS)

 

I love Teeling whisky. I visited the distillery in Dublin in December of 2020 and it was a wonderful experience. I've actually strolled through the Blackpitts neighborhood that this whisk is named for. 

Peated Irish whiskies are pretty uncommon - the only other one I can remember having was Connemara, which I liked but didn't love. This one is triple distilled, of course - they started with peated Speyside malt at the highest concentration they could find (55 ppm) and apparently after the triple distillation it ended up around 15 ppm, which is - in terms of scotch - approximately Springbank territory. 

Croftongea 10 Year (Exclusive Malts)

 

Exclusive Malts was an imprint or brand or wing of the independent bottler The Creative Whisky Company, which was founded and run by David Stirk, a veteran of Douglas Laing and Cadenheads. 

For whatever reason, Exclusive Malts bottles were widely available here in the Washington DC region in the mid-2010s. Unfortunately the Creative Whisky Company apparently folded in August of 2018 and all their stocks were sold off. The website is no longer accessible, which is often the final and most conclusive mark of death.

Bruichladdich Bere Barley 2010 Second Take

 

This is my second look at my favorite bottling by Bruichladdich, the Bere Barley 2010. Bere is a very very old six-row variety of barley; the grain used in this bottling was grown on the far northern Orkney Islands. Bere only yields about 50% what modern barley varieties do, so it's fallen from favor almost entirely - but it also has a really outstanding, rich buttery taste to it. This was an experiment by Bruichladdich, and in my mind it was 100% successful. It's a wonderful bottle. 

Amaro Nardini

 

Another Italian amaro on the block tonight - this time a much heralded family-owned product called Amaro Nardini. The Nardini distillery is in the general Venice/Padua metropolitan area, in far northeastern Italy, and they have apparently been making this since 1870 or so - in fact, their website makes the claim they are Italy's first distillery (!). Bartolo Nardini was born in 1739 and they mostly made grappa from the leftovers produced during wine production. 

Kilchoman USA Small Batch Release No. 2 (NAS)

 I'm a long-time fan of Kilchoman, the small, family-run distillery on Islay, but I have to admit that their price point (everything hovers around or above the $100 mark) tends to dissuade me from buying too many bottles. However, I saw this dusty bottle on a back shelf at Batch 13 liquors on 14th St NW here in Washington DC, and couldn't resist. 

Amaro Soldatini

 

Another fairly unusual/rare amaro, at least here in the US: Amaro Soldatini, from Distilleria Gualco, in the northwest of Italy near France (between Turin and Genoa). Interestingly, despite the name, the distillers themselves call this a "grappa senza nome" - Grappa Without a Name. 

The distillery was founded in 1870 by a former cooper, Paolo Gualco. The entire history of the family ownership can be found on their website - it's a great read! I absolutely delight in the black and white photo they include of the old Italian man smoking a cheroot. Right up my alley. 

Craigellachie 10 Year (Five Lions)

 

Here is an independent bottling so obscure, I couldn't even find a clean picture of it anywhere on the net (!). Five Lions is a UK independent bottler whose mission to bottle exception single casks. I have not heard of them before, and the only review I could find of this bottle was pretty bare bones, so I have no idea what I'm in for. A fairly obscure bottle if there ever was one.

Glencadam 15 Year

Glencadam is a Highland distillery that was built in 1825 by one George Cooper, and has changed hands many, many times over the last 200 years. Most recently - and gloriously - it was purchased by Angus Dundee in 2003, who immediately improved every aspect of whisky. This 15 year expression is bottled at 46%, no coloring, no filtering. Huzzah for Angus Dundee! It's part of the blend recipe for Ballantine's, which is a blend I have enjoyed in the past. It's not far from Fettercairn, and also not super distant from Royal Lochnagar, Edradour, and Blair Athol. 

Glen Grant 17 Year (Signatory)

 

It's been some time since I explored the Signatory range of independently bottled scotch. Too long, in fact. Signatory provided me with my first, valuable looks at Mortlach, Linkwood, Dailuaine, and Clynelish. This bottle is of Glen Grant - a Speyside distillery from whom I have liked everything I've tried thus far. I have a Scotch Malt Whisky Society Glen Grant bottle in my cabinet as well, "Harvest Hayride Happiness," and it's astoundingly fragrant, fruity, and delicious. This bottle, at 43% ABV, is much less potent, but I suspect will be a very easy sipper and full of flavor. No colorating, no chill filtration!

Caol Ila 10 Year (SMWS 53.386 "Phenomenal")

 The final dram of the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") March outturn preview tasting at the Jack Rose Saloon in Washington DC on 2/28/22. Predictably, they ended with a peated expression, since peat tends to dominate your palate after you've sampled it. This is yet another ~10 year Caol Ila, which they SMWS seems to have an unlimited stock of. My notes tell me I've only had three of these bottles, but I feel like it's been twice that number. They stick with you.

Glen Scotia 9 Year (SMWS 93.170 "Mermaid Karate")

 

The fifth and penultimate bottle of the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") March outturn tasting preview at the Jack Rose Saloon in Washington DC, this was my favorite, I think. It certainly has the best name of the night! "Mermaid Karate" is right up there with the most memorable names I've seen like "Doctor Blowtorch" and "Nice to Meat You." 

Glen Scotia is probably the least heralded of the vaunted Campbeltown distilleries, after Springbank (and Longrow and Hazelburn) and Kilkerran. I hear the fewest things about Glen Scotia, which has a VERY distinctive signature series of flavors that this bottle encapsulates perfectly. 

Strathmill 11 Year (SMWS 100.27 "Colorful and Flavorful")

 

This was the fourth cask sampled at the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") March outturn preview tasting at the Jack Rose Saloon on 2/28/22, and probably the crowd favorite (along with the Inchmurrin 25 year). This was the first sherried whisky of the night and the nose was as open and bountiful as the Inchmurrin was closed!

Strathmill is another anonymous Diageo distillery that mostly used to produce blend fodder for J&B (among others). The name is Gaelic for "shallow valley mill." 

Inchmurrin 25 Year (SMWS 112.83 "Rara Avis")

The third cask tasted at the Scotch Malt Whisky Society March outturn preview tasting event at the Jack Rose saloon on 2/28/22 was a 25 year old Inchmurrin (Loch Lomond). This was immediately more interesting than the previous two (a young Glen Moray and an older Clynelish). The nose presented as more complex, yet also curiously muted - a fascinating mixture. 

Clynelish 17 Year (SMWS 26.179 "Eastern Coastlines")

 

The second dram of the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") March outturn preview tasting. This was also immediately identifiable as Clynelish right on the nose - so much wax! - even without knowing the distillery because of the order page provided online. 

Glen Moray 7 Year (SMWS 35.298 "Big Bumper Bag of Buttons")

 

I attended the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") March Outturn preview tasting at the Jack Rose Saloon here in Washington DC last night - it was an interesting experience. They gave us all small pours (~.5-1 oz) of the six casks being released, and the entire evening was structured as a guessing game. Our host was Mike Hong, who was weirdly familiar to me, but perhaps I just know from seeing him at a bar here and there. He did a good job of engaging people and moving the night along from cask to cask. 

Golden Moon Amer Dit Picon

 

I love Golden Moon - a Colorado distillery that opened in 2008 and utilized old world production methods from the get-go. I am a particular fan of their Creme de Violette - an usually rich, leathery violet liquer - but this is their difficult-to-source Amer Dit Picon. Picon, of course, is the French term for an orange-flavored liqueur. Usually made with orange peel, chinchona bark, and gentian root, it's a staple of the amaro scene.

Glen Moray Port Cask Finish (NAS)

 

Glen Moray is one of those distilleries I first encountered in turbocharged single cask independent bottles - they are rich and sweet and full of interesting flavors, in that setting. But their official bottlings mostly seemed geared at the lower end of the market, and this Port Cask Finish bottling was only $28 - half the cost of most other standard bottles. Thanks to Rob Martin for this delicious sample!

Don Ciccio & Figli Amaro Tonico Ferro-Kino

 

Don Ciccio & Figli is located right here in Washington DC, in the Ivy City neighborhood. I have had, at this point, basically their entire lineup of amaros - and all are good. This is the most recent I've sampled: a tonic-style amaro made with chinchona bark, which has quinine in it, cooked/roasted on iron plates before maceration, unaged, bottled at 20% ABV. 

This style of amaro dates to at least 1881, according to the story on the bottle. Their house blend of herbs is combined in terracotta amphorae (!), which is certainly old world style - I appreciate that. Let's dig in:

Cynar 70

 

Ah, Cynar... how I love thee. The preeminent artichoke-based liqueur, this is the vaunted 70 proof (35% ABV) version of it, widely used as a straight substitute for Campari. In fact, this is made by Campari, it's compromised of 13 herbs and plants, chief among them being artichoke. 

Used in many many cocktails (even more during the hipster cocktail explosion of the 2000s/2010s), Cynar has a very distinctive taste that really needs to be experienced, and can be considered both an aperitif and digestif. Apparently Italians have been making artichoke liqueurs for centuries. Let's immediately sip some: 

Amaro Dell'Erbalista

 

I have a deep and abiding love for Italian amaros - bitter herbal liqueurs - and eventually I will review all the 3-4 dozen that I have sampled here on the blog, as a change of pace and flavor. 

I want to kick it off with this amazing organic digestif I recently had, from the Varnelli family in the mountains of central Italy - Amaro Dell'Erbolista. Unfiltered, made with spices and herbs combined over a wood fire, and sweetened only with organic honey, it's rapidly become one of my very favorites. Let's explore the bitter side:

Clynelish 14 Year Second Take

 It's been a year and a half since I last reviewed the official bottling of vaunted distillery Clynelish, and it's long overdue for a return look. 

Aged 14 years in ex-bourbon casks, although rumors persist that a little refill sherry casking is present as well - I came across that claim on numerous websites - and bottled at 46%.

Diageo is infamously mum about most of the important aspects of their various single malts. 95% of the output of Clynelish goes to Johnnie Walker, as far as I can tell, despite their very high reputation in the independent bottling scene. 

Is this colored? Almost certainly. Is it chill-filtered? Very probably. But my memory is that the famously waxy character of Clynelish still shines through, and this is a particularly delectable single malt. Let's explore...

Bunnahabhain 10 Year (Clan Denny) Second Take

 

Almost exactly a year has gone by since I was gifted a dram of this by my good friend Rob Martin. Tonight, while out walking around, I wandered into Metro Liquors in the Adams Morgan neighborhood of Washington DC and they had a fire sale on this 2018 bottling to make room for new things. I knew I'd had it, but my memory was scant, faded. So I picked up a bottle.

Kilkerran Heavily Peated Batch 4 (NAS)

 

I have enjoyed both expressions of Kilkerran that I've had previously - the 8 year and the 12 year - and tonight I am sampling the "heavily peated, batch 4" expression of their Peat-in-Progress series. 

Kilkerran is a product of one of the three remaining Campbeltown distilleries (Glengyle, which is owned by Springbank, another favorite distillery of mine). This is batch 4, no age expression (apparently is 5-6 years old), was bottled at 58.6% ABV, matured 80/20% in bourbon/sherry casks. Let's immediately dig into some young Campbeltown glory:

Mortlach "Game of Thrones" 15 Year

 

It's safe to say now that the Diageo "Game of Thrones" scotch experiment was - sadly - not a success. These attempts to lure your average HBO viewer to the world of expensive liquor was (perhaps) well intentioned, and maybe even well executed, but didn't really pay off. Most scotch drinkers I know considered it some kind of joke, and all the liquor store owners I chatted with said the bottled were hard as hell to move.

The original Game of Thrones collection had the following bottlings:

• Game of Thrones House Stark – Dalwhinnie Winter’s Frost
• Game of Thrones House Tully – Singleton of Glendullan Select
• Game of Thrones House Targaryen – Cardhu Gold Reserve
• Game of Thrones House Lannister – Lagavulin 9 Year Old
• Game of Thrones The Night’s Watch – Oban Bay Reserve
• Game of Thrones House Greyjoy – Talisker Select Reserve
• Game of Thrones House Baratheon – Royal Lochnagar 12 Year Old
• Game of Thrones House Tyrell – Clynelish Reserve

The final bottle was this - the "Six Kingdoms" Mortlach 15 Year

To the Best Drinking Partner I Ever Had

 

Glenfarclas 21 Year (Second Take)

 

It's been almost exactly a year since I last had this magnificent 21-year scotch from Glenfarclas. Quite possibly the best-priced 20+ year scotch on the market (I obtained it for $135, less than even the 17 year goes for!), I remember this being full of fascinating, balanced flavors. 100% aged in Oloroso sherry casks - the standard Glenfarclas house style - and bottled at 43% ABV, this was one of the highlights of my 2021 drinking year. 

Glenmorangie 18 Year

 

I have always respected Glenmorangie as the best of the Glen-centered core expressions of Scotch - for years, their 10 Year was the best available single malt in the $30-35 range. Well-balanced, smooth, endlessly crushable, it had a little of everything and always seemed richer and more refined than the competition (Glenfiddich, Glenlivet especially). 

I decided today to try one of their "prestige" expressions for the first time ever - the 18 year, which Glenmorangie calls "Extremely Rare." Unsure if that is actually factually true, or marketing spin. 

Ardbeg Grooves (NAS)

 

I have held onto this bottle for some time, in a secret "emergency scotch" stash, and only remembered tonight that I had yet to review it! So here we go: the Ardbeg Day 2018 release, aged an undisclosed period of years in super heavily charred red wine casks (!). Very interesting - I think scotch and red wine casks go hand-in-glove. This one is bottled at 46%. Thanks to Ardbeg rep Clarke Boyer for hosting the Ardbeg event where I ordered this from Ace Beverage in Wesley Heights in Washington DC. 

Wild Turkey Longbranch 8 Year Bourbon

 

One thing I've noticed about smaller scotch blogs (like this one) is that reviewers inevitably end up reviewing non-scotch alcohol every so often. This is due both to (1) scotch fatigue and (2) the high price of reviewing many bottles of scotch per annum. 

So in addition to my rum excursions, I am also going to occasionally review bourbon, gin, etc. The focus will still be primarily on scotch, but to keep everyone entertained I'll toss in a few like this every now and again.

Worthy Park 7 Year Jamaican Rum (SMWS R11.13 "Dunder Heid!")

 Another side jaunt into the world of interesting rums! My last bottle, a fascinating and challenging bottle from Guyana, was a real stunner. So I took a chance on this seven year bottling from Worthy Park - made in a pot still, aged 7 years in a second fill barrel (I think the aging occurs in England). 

This is nicknamed "Dunder Heid!" which refers to dunder, a remnant of rum distilling that is extremely funky and high in esters, and is left at the bottom of the boiler - much like sour mash, with bourbon. So this is going to be super super funky. 

Glen Grant 14 Year (SMWS 9.224 "Harvest Hayride Happiness")

 

This year's Burns Night bottle from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") is a 14 year Glen Grant - a distillery I've only ever sampled in official bottling form, their lovely 15 year, which was full to the brim with vanilla, chocolate, coffee, pears. It was bold, and a real pleasure. So I am hoping for great things here. 

Glenfarclas 8 Year (SMWS 1.246 "A One Like No Other")

 

I wasn't planning on buying anything this month, especially not a young Speysider, but I saw this bottle in the January outturn and just couldn't resist. A peated Glenfarclas (!). Glenfarclas is a family-owned Speyside distillery known primarily for very heavily sherried whiskies, and I have never seen a peated variant of any of their whiskies, ever. Not one. 

So when this showed up, I had to buy it and try it. Apparently the story is: this spent 8 years in a 2nd fill barrel... and the first fill of the barrel must have held heavily, heavily peated whisky. When a whisky ages in a wood barrel, it's not just the oils and esters and other chemicals in the wood that are imparted into the liquid... the liquid, for its part, sends chemicals and oils and esters right back into the wood, in turn. And here, heavy peat and smoke were residing in the barrel used here. 

Ardmore 12 Year (SMWS 66.206 "Magnificently Manky!")

 

Sometimes shipping alcohol from state to state here in the United States can be prohibitively expensive - between 25% and 33% of the cost of a single bottle, oftentimes. Thus, when placing orders with the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS"), I usually find it best to buy at least two bottles to distribute the cost a little better. More than once, I have bought a whole bundle that contained a bottle or two I wanted, just to maximize my booze-against-shipping rates. 

This 12 year Ardmore was one such "plus one" bottle, bought to accompany the peated Glenfarclas I couldn't resist. And I have been a longterm fan of Ardmore for a long while now, so this was an easy pick.

Spade and Bushel 10 Year Cask Strength Irish Whisky

 

Another treat provided by the venerable Rob Martin, whisky connoisseur deluxe! And another departure from my usual single malt scotch focus. This was released in a limited edition of 5000 half-sized bottles, at cask strength (57.5% ABV), after aging for 10 years in unknown casks. 

Ireland doesn't have the same oak restrictions that the US and Scotland have - they only require "wooden" casks, since oak is hard to come by in Ireland and the whisky industry would have long ago extinguished the species from the island if they were required to use it - thanks to Teeling distillery tour for that bit of info. But I suspect that this spent its years in oak anyway, just based on the drying tannins I taste. 

Bottled by the Connaught Whisky Company, the actual distiller here is unknown. Let's investigate:

Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie 21/137 (NAS)

 

Thank you to mom for this unexpected Christmas gift! Almost a year after my last look at Bruichladdich and their core expression, let's have another glass. An unpeated Islay made with all Scottish barley, this is bottle 21/137, which carries the following information on the Bruichladdich website (and kudos to them for providing this): 

Old Tub Bourbon by Jim Beam

Here is another rare "general spirits" review, much like the Guyanese rum review from a little while back. Thanks to Rob Martin for sharing the bottle! Old Tub is an old school unfiltered bourbon made by Jim Beam. This website describes better than I can the exact ins-and-outs of Old Tub. I will note only that the only filtration they do is particulate (to remove little pieces of wood that break off the barrel), and since it's Bottled in Bond it's aged at least 4 years and is at least 50% ABV. Let's dig in: 

Ardnamurchan AD/03.21:02

 

This is the inaugural bottle released in the American market. Here are the basic stats: Aged somewhere around ~6 years, only 5004 bottles released, 35% ex-sherry casks and 65% ex-bourbon, 50/50 peated/unpeated, non-chill-filtered, uncolored, bottled at 46.8% ABV. 

Ardnamurchan is the much-heralded new distillery in the western Highlands, and I was much intrigued by the first bottle I had through the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS"). Thank you to Rob Martin for this one! Let's see how this one comes across...

Highland Park 13 Year (SMWS 4.301 "Sooty Clouds")

 

The third and final bottle of a trio of independently bottled Highland Parks from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS"), as part of a distillery deep dive they did in December of 2021. I couldn't resist - I think independent Highland Park is the best Highland Park. 

This one, like "A Horned Beast" (4.300) before it, is considered peated rather than oily and coastal by the standards of the SMWS flavor categories. I'm curious - normally Highland Park isn't considered super peaty, but rather quite lightly peated, almost as an afterthought. 

Highland Park 13 Year (SMWS 4.300 "A Horned Beast")

 

I'm intrigued that this independent bottling of Highland Park from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") is considered peated (and not even lightly peated!) instead of oily and coastal, the usual category determination. I have never had a well-and-truly-peated bottling of Highland Park, so I'm ultra curious about this one. 

Part of a trio of 13 year Highland Parks released by SMWS as part of a distillery deep dive, this is the second one I'm partaking in. I love independently bottled Highland Park, which is coastal, fragrant, lightly sweet and salty, and filled with personality. 

Highland Park 13 Year (SMWS 4.298 "I See Seashore")

 

This is part of a "distillery deep dive" in Highland Park from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS"), a trio of 13 year bottles that all come from the same revatting experiment as two lovely previous bottles I had from SMWS: "Dining by the Harbour" and "By the Beautiful Sea." 

I have consistently found that independently bottled Highland Park (often called "Orkney Distillery" or "Unnamed Orkney" on independent bottle labels) is where the spirit really shines, divorced from the marketing juggernaut that continues to amuse and frustrate the scotch-loving public with watered down bottles and overripe names. 

I almost wish they would go way over the top with the whole effort. Instead of "Viking Honor" and "Viking Scars" and "Viking Heart" and "Loyalty of the Wolf" and "Spirit of the Bear" etc etc etc (ugh), they should get creative with the naming. "Untamable Fury of the Malmsteen" ... "The Angriest Rooster" ... "A Barbarian, Reading a Book" ... "Dragons Dreaming of Scary Children" and so on. I would be 1000% more likely to actually buy a bottle if they had some humor or personality. Instead, I continue to boycott the ridiculous expressions, with the sole exception of the surprisingly good Cask Strength bottles, which really deserve more attention. I look forward to reviewing the Batch No. 2 very soon.  

Ardnamurchan 5 Year (SMWS 149.2 "Peaty Peninsula")

 

Ever since my friend Rob had a bottle of the newly released whisky from Highland distillery Ardnamurchan, I've been very interested in trying some. This month's outturn from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") offered a 5 year expression, aged entirely in a first-fill Oloroso sherry butt - I couldn't say no!

Glenfarclas 7 Year (SMWS 1.238 "Well-Danced Upon Flood")

 

I am quite a fan of Glenfarclas, and will nearly always take a chance on an independent expression of their spirit when I can find it. This young 7-year bottling from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") fit the bill nicely. It's actually the second bottle I've had that follows this casking: 5 years in ex-bourbon, 2 year finish in PX sherry oak. This one is apparently much closer to the "normal" Glenfarclas sherry-forward profile. 

Caol Ila 10 Year (SMWS 53.357 "Smoke and Smirr")

 

Yet another ~10-12 year bottle of single cask Caol Ila from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS"). In the past, I have liked a few of these, and one ("Industrial Chimney Soot") was quite distinctly good indeed. Nicknamed "Smoke and Smirr," which originates in a poem called "The Smokey Smirr O' Rain" by George Campbell Hay: 

A misty mornin’ doon the shore wi a hushed an’ caller air,
an’ ne’er a breath frae East or West tie sway the rashes there,
a sweet, sweet scent frae Laggan’s birks gaed breathin’ on its ane,
their branches hingin beaded in the smoky smirr o rain.

The hills aroond war silent wi the mist alang the braes.
The woods war derk an’ quiet wi dewy, glintin’ sprays.
The thrushes didna raise for me, as I gaed by alane,
but a wee, wae cheep at passin’ in the smoky smirr o rain.

Rock an’ stane lay glisterin’ on aa the heichs abune.
Cool an’ kind an’ whisperin’ it drifted gently doon,
till hill an’ howe war rowed in it, an’ land an’ sea war gane.
Aa was still an’ saft an’ silent in the smoky smirr o rain.

Craigellachie 17 Year (SMWS 44.143 "Good Traditional Fare")

 

Now here is a bottle I am greatly looking forward to: a 17 year single cask Craigellachie from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS"). I have adored every single Craigellachie SMWS has released, and the last one, a 13 year bottle called "The Fruits of One's Labors" was outstanding: a succulent mixture of apples, pie crust, and meaty sulfur notes. Wonderful stuff. 

Craigellachie means "rocky hill" - I imagine that's where the words "crag" and "craggy" originate - and refers to an outcropping that overlooks the Spey river, across from the Macallan distillery. Craigellachie is owned by Bacardi, and I have to say - based on what I've had, they are doing all the right things. It was built in 1891, and is currently a major part of Dewar's blends; they produce 4,000,000 litres of alcohol a year.  

Inchgower 13 Year (SMWS 18.38 "The Happy Ponderer")

 

Here is a new one to me - Inchgower, a four-still distillery on the outskirts of Buckie in Moray, Scotland. Dating from 1871, it was owned by Bell's for many years, and is currently owned by Diageo. It remains a major component of Bell's blended whisky, which I always liked just fine. I have never, not once in a decade of drinking primarily single malts, seen or even heard of a bottle of Inchgower, anywhere. According to the cask coding that the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") uses, this is only the 38th cask they've ever obtained from Inchgower - a real rarity!

Research: Phenols and Esters

Phenols and esters are two volatile molecular compounds that cause many of the flavors in alcoholic drinks, Scotch included. There is actually a considerable body of scientific research into these compounds and exactly how they are created, destroyed, and generally interact. 

If you ever had a glass of Scotch and wondered where that rubber tire aroma came from, or lavender soap, or that *exact* aroma of charred pineapples ... these articles will help explain. 

Naked Grouse Blend

 

An interesting offering from the Grouse family of blended whiskies, this one has been aged in first-fill sherry butts, and consists heavily of (apparently) Macallan and Glenturret and Highland Park. Color me intrigued! Thanks to Rob Martin for the sample! Bottled at 43% ABV, let's just drink the damned stuff!

Compass Box Great King Street Glasgow Blend, Single Marrying Vat

 

First off, thanks to Rob Martin for this sample! I always admire the Compass Box whiskies, and have been curious about this bottle for a while now. 

Compass Box manufactures some really excellent blends, and even the worst bottles I've had from them are pretty damned interesting. This one is, apparently, a love letter to Glasgow; the website opens by saying 

"Aromas of sherry and smoke permeate the streets of Glasgow

In his 1930s book ‘Whisky’, Aeneas MacDonald teaches us that Glaswegians historically preferred fuller bodied and more flavour-packed whiskies than people in other parts of the world. So what better name for a whisky such as this?

Glaswegians are also famed for their sense of humour, which is why the city’s Wellington statue – traditionally dressed down with a traffic cone – is featured on the front label."

Highland Park 20 Year (SMWS 4.277 "A Punch and a Pout")

  

If I'm being completely honest, I only really bought this because it supported a good charity (Fisher House Foundation) on Veteran's Day here in the US, and because it was the least expensive of the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS") Black Label bottlings - their oldest, most mature offerings. I simply couldn't justify $1000+ for an ancient Mortlach, etc. 

But I do quite like independent bottlings of Highland Park, especially the recent revattings I've had from SMWS - "Dining by the Harbor" and "By the Beautiful Sea" were both amazing bottles. This is a 17 year Highland Park (those 17 years in ex-bourbon) that was revatted and finished another 3 years in a refill ex-bourbon hogshead. Here are the official notes:

David vs Goliath - The Battle of the Single Cask Sherry Bombs

 

I normally don't do posts like this, but I couldn't resist - I got both these bottles about a week apart and they begged for comparison. 

DAVID: A 13 year bottle of Dailuaine (a distillery owned and operated by Diageo, 98% of their production goes into Johnnie Walker), matured for 11 years in an Oloroso butt and another 2 year finish in a Pedro Ximenez butt. Bottled at 57.5% ABV by the Scotch Malt Whisky Society ("SMWS"). 

GOLIATH: A 12 year bottle Macallan (a renowned distillery owned and operated by The Edrington Group, famous for its high prices and sherry casking), matured for 10 years in an Oloroso butt and then revatted and finished for 2 years in a Pedro Ximenez butt. Bottled at 63.9% ABV by the SMWS.

So we have two massive sherry bombs. Can the smaller distillery keep up? Let's find out...